American beauty
By MERIDITH FORD
Published on: 07/27/04
Overall rating:
AMERICANS ARE PURITANICAL
as a rule. And try as we might to shed our prudish weight, we still
seem a little staunchly starched compared with other cultures.
Perhaps nowhere but in our indigenous foods — and the way we cook
them — do we ever truly break from form and relax. New American
cuisine embraces a certain comfort factor. It is fun and approachable
without becoming gaudy and contrite. It is sophisticated yet doesn't
intimidate. It teaches but never oversteps boundaries. It makes
mistakes but is all the more likable for it.
And Kevin Rathbun, chef-owner of Rathbun's in Inman Park, is a
master at preparing it. His new restaurant embraces the maxim that
food should be enjoyable, creative and innovative, but never fussy.
The menu is a textbook lesson of what new American cuisine is — a
reflection of local tastes and ingredients melded with concepts of
preparation that draw from family rituals, formal dining principles
and just plain old common sense.
Simply put, this man knows what ingredients to mix with what and
make it all come out tasting real good. Need proof? Try his
white corn — sweet, pan-charred and still just a little bit crunchy,
mixed with creamily melted, mildly nutty Gouda and a dice of bright
tomatoes. Or sultry smoked salmon, so velvety you barely need to chew
it, with a creamy mix of heated, heady habaneros, a lemon-zest
vinaigrette and a dab of baby greens over a bite-sized square of
toasted tortilla. It is at once mild and spicy, sweet and salty, warm
and cold.
Rathbun, at 41, has finally hit his peak — and his stride — at the
same time. He cooks with a firm, decisive hand and isn't afraid to
make mistakes. That's not to say he is impulsive, though. It was a big
gamble to go from the security of being the executive chef of the
Buckhead Life Restaurant Group to opening a restaurant in a former
warehouse on the outskirts of Cabbagetown, where its previous tenant,
Virginia's, had failed to make a go of it. That may be why his menu is
full of offerings that sound and taste good. He knows it.
He ought to. Like his food, his is a chapter in the quintessential
American success story. Gleaned at an early age (14) by esteemed chef
Bradley Ogden (then at the American Restaurant, now the chef-owner of
the Lark Creek Restaurant Group in California), he laddered his way to
Brennan's in Houston, then to famed Commander's Palace (under
then-chef Emeril Lagasse) in New Orleans. Stephan Pyles hired him to
work at Baby Routh in Dallas, where he was nominated for a James Beard
award.
Rathbun then blazed his way onto the restaurant scene in Atlanta as
the executive chef at NAVA, where he garnered praise for his innate
ability to do exactly what he does at Rathbun's — cull ingredients and
methods indigenous to a culture and then blow them out of the water
flavor-wise. His roster of restaurants since NAVA reads like a what's
what of the Atlanta mise en scene: He opened Bluepointe, then became
executive chef of Buckhead Life. Last year, he broke away to open a
place of his own.
All this from a guy's kind of guy who, when asked what his favorite
food is, will tell you unequivocally and without hesitation: "corn."
And corn shows up in various and sundry ways all over his menu:
grits; roasted and creamed as a side dish with Gouda cheese; as masa
in tortillas. Juicy, sweet sea scallops are seared with a heavy
seasoning of salt, placed over a silky, chile-seasoned hollandaise and
served with some of the best grits from here to Memphis — creamy, with
bits of smoked ham scattered throughout. After one bite, I wanted to
be dipped in them. Bite-sized bluepoint oysters are cornmeal battered
and served with a luscious, cream-cheesy, red chile paste and a
dipping sauce of light soy, sugar and rice vinegar.
And the scallops are a perfect example of Rathbun's experience and
decisiveness. They are clearly, intentionally oversalted. The effect
works for some and doesn't for others.
For those it doesn't, there are plenty of other things that will
please. Braised brisket of beef, steeped in a smoky, rustic tomato
sauce, is so tender it can barely be picked up with a fork. A cheesy
quesadilla as its "go with" is overpowered by the heat of poblano
peppers, an oddity since this pepper is usually more seductive than
hot.
Pricier items are cleverly referred to as "second mortgage" plates
on the menu. One, a Maine lobster served in a soft taco, gets lost in
the nutty, mild heat of a creamy cascabel sauce. It looks positively
pedestrian on the plate, too — a rolled mound of almost unidentifiable
ingredients, which is in sharp contrast to Rathbun's usual flair for
fastidious plate presentation.
Desserts, from pastry chef Kirk Parks, follow suit to Rathbun's
all-American mode: The ice creams are house spun (read: they taste
real good), but the best of the bunch is a miniature banana-peanut
butter pie, apparently something Parks plucked from heaven's menu. It
sounds so simple, and it is — a buttery pastry shell lined with just a
wisp of peanut butter and filled with a creamy, scrumptious banana
pudding, then crowned with a dreamy, toasted meringue. Elvis would
have been proud.
A key lime shortcake makes a good showing, too; its tiny, tart,
buttery biscuit filled with sweet whipped cream covers a tempting
dollop of sweet, sugary peaches. In the end, though, it plays second
fiddle to the peanut butter-and-banana cream pie.
The restaurant itself is as fetching as the menu. The space was
redesigned by Atlanta's dream team, the Johnson Studio. Mod and
vibrant, the design has managed to keep the industrial look of the
interior, while warming it up a bit: bright swaths of fuschia blend
with gray tones, while oversized stove-pipe pendant fixtures dangle
from the high ceilings. The kitchen is open and luminous, and Rathbun
often wanders away from it at quieter moments (which are rare) to walk
through the dining room and talk with guests.
Sitting in a banquette against a monochromatic gray,
pottery-studded wall, it feels as if you could be almost anywhere in
the world — Manhattan, Mexico City, maybe even London. But you aren't.
You are in Atlanta, where Rathbun's serves grits as if they were
caviar, and eggplant steak fries sprinkled with confectioner's sugar
with no prudish apologies. Any questions?
Food: New American cuisine, with a bit of a Southern accent,
plus flavors from the Southwest and New Orleans
Service: For the most part service is prompt and always
friendly. Service and kitchen can run slowly, especially at peak hours
when the restaurant is very busy (which is almost all the time).
Setting: Mod, vibrant industrial setting in an old
warehouse, with tones of gray and fuschia and impressive suspended
stove-pipe pendants. One wall is bathed in brick painted in gray and
dotted with gray pottery in a monochromatic theme that when backlit,
almost looks like moving water
Address, telephone: 112 Krog Street, Atlanta, 404-524-8280
Hours: Open for dinner Monday through Saturday, 5:30 to 11
Price range: One of the most reasonably priced menus in the
area. The menu is divided: Small plates, raw plates and soup bowls
cost $5 to $8; big plates are $14 to $20. "Second mortgage" plates are
$27 to $33. Sides are $4. Desserts are smallish, $3.15 each or four
for $10.
Credit cards: Visa, MasterCard, American Express, Diners
Club, Discover
Recommended dishes: Bluepoint oysters two ways, short-smoked
salmon tostadas with habenero peppers and baby greens, Yaya's eggplant
steak fries with confectioner's sugar, creamed white corn and Gouda
cheese, peanut butter-banana cream pie
Full bar or wine/beer: Yes
Reservations: Accepted
Vegetarian selections: Mushroom risotto with Holly Farms aged
goat cheese, Krog Street (house-made) mozzarella with tomatoes and
torn basil, Shaved zucchini with Parmigiano Reggiano and lemon
verbena, hand-cut French fries with blue cheese fondue
Children: Welcome, but the atmosphere here is really a "see and
be seen" crowd
Parking: Valet parking or parking lot
Wheelchair access: Yes
Smoking: In lounge area only and on the patio Noise
level: Very high. You may be hoarse the morning after.
Patio: Yes, with lots of seating
Takeout: Yes; but no call-ins. Ordering at the bar is
preferred.